After Manila #2 – Decorations

I love including minor details into puzzles. For example did you notice the siren-shaped blanks in the coffee wordsearch? Two big examples of minor features in Manila:

Bulletin Board
A childhood of Mario Kart courses made me a huge fan of unused details. Though “unused” is not entirely true since it certainly adds depth to the gaming experience. Incorporating details (like signs on a Mario Kart course) into a logic puzzle contest on a blog like this is sadly pointless. Starting at the Harbour to read a paragraph of introduction might come to mind.


After solving the commodity puzzles, another seemingly meaningless feature appears: the Bulletin Board. I’ve had the idea of solvers leaving their mark as the make their progress at the back of my head for a while now. It takes Manila for an excuse to introduce it since both the Harbour and the Bulletin Board housed sneaky hints to Rick the Pilot’s whereabouts (as mentioned in the previous post).


With only 6 solvers posting, the reception of the Bulletin Board was quite dim. Ed was actually first if you exclude Rick. Then the board was left to rust for two weeks until Alan, 11th person to finish, came along to break the ice. Also I’m left to wonder who Rato is. Perhaps his boat capsized somewhere en route to Manila Bay Pier?

Captain Alokin
Our pirate had a rather brief showing in Puzzle 4, that’s very little to invest in a character. The Captain and his crew was originally a four-part mini puzzle series; invade his ship, prepare cannonballs, fire and take the loot.

What you saw was only the “fire” part (Outside Battleships) since three other puzzles all broke and I had already spent too long tweaking them to no avail. The loot at the end was a loop puzzle which would spell out MALACHITE. Rick was also going to give you malachite taking you to the finish – but alas, he had to give you a random string of letters instead.

Why Alokin? That’s a shout-out to Nikola Zivanovic, who is currently the highest-ranked solver at SOTR to have never won a prize. Closely behind is Ivan Koswara, both at 8 events and still without a prize. So that’s the drill. If you don’t win, take consolation in the fact that you can become a bad guy in SOTR. Perhaps Ivan can be an earth-hungry alien next time…

After Manila #1 – Rick the Pilot

Before the event started, a little info was given about the board game.
postman1Yet in the journey, there was no apparent way to find a pilot. And a lot of you wondered what was up with Pilot Service. Second clue was at the Harbour where several signs were plastered with notices, one of which was…

postman2Or you could have reached the Bulletin Board and found that Pilot Service was indeed available. Unfortunately it was locked.

postman5So if pilots are available, how do we hitch a ride?
The Bulletin Board might help…

postman3The coffee house word search had blank cells that spell out a trivia question for the answer key. Most of you might work out the question without having to even find all the words.
But what happens if you did find all the words?

IMG_6291Reading the leftover letters: “Hello there! I’m Rick, I am a pilot. Can you buy me a coffee? I forgot my wallet. Wow! Thank you! Say, should you be in a leaky situation, call me. My number is the two digit number on the first oil barrel.”

So what is this leaky situation?

postman4 Remember this other sign at the Harbour?
The picture of oil barrel is similar to the one on the map. This suggests that somewhere along the journey you will have some sort of oil leak.

Sure enough, at puzzle 3, this happens and Rick does come to the rescue.
The double-digit number on the first barrel is 48 and this opens up “Pilot Service”. Most of you probably haven’t seen it but here is the pilot puzzle:

Find 5 planes in the grid. Cells occupied by a plane cannot touch each other, not even diagonally. Each plane parts have different weights. An example of a plane is given. The numbers outside the grid represent the total weight of all the plane segments in that row or column.


Once this is solved, Rick takes you straight to Manila Bay Pier, skipping the last three puzzles entirely!

I only know of two people that hitched a ride with Rick; first was Nick Brady. But only after he went all the way to Puzzle 5, couldn’t solve the puzzle because it initially had multiple solutions, and then return to find Rick.

“I ended up coming here thanks to Rick’s Pilot puzzle, but I had made it all the way up to a solution to puzzle 5 that I believe is valid, but wasn’t accepted. Only then did I try tracking Rick down, solving his puzzle hoping for a clue and to my surprise being given a direct answer.”

Another person was Ivan Koswara who had an alternate (better?) approach. Once he got the message at the coffee house hinting at a two-digit number, he immediately tried all possible two digit combinations to hack open Pilot Service! Eventually he got to 48 and solved… “Perhaps my most favorite puzzle among the [puzzles] I solved”.
You cheater, you!

 Did anyone else find Rick?

Results of Manila

Manila Bay Pier has welcomed its last visitor and is now closed. 23 solvers survived the journey and carried four commodities to start a new life in the capital.

Here is the order they reached Manila Bay Pier: E H, Nick Brady, Zach Polansky, Gavriel Hirsch, Kishore Kumar, Nikola Zivanovic, Antonis Lalatsas, Antonios Fantakis, Ken Levine, James McGowan, Alan O’Donnell, Branko Ceranic, Thomas Powell, Robert Vollmert, Sinchai Rungsangrattanakul, Arturo Vial, Michael Mosshammer, Raphael Lehrer, Ivan Koswara, Matej Uher, Andrew Brecher, Franck Wallez and Zbigniew Laskowski.

At the pier, all entrants took turns devaluing certain items and investing in commodities of their choice. Several people, one of whom is James McGowan, found that … “a 2-1-1-1 investment will always be middle of the field, so I need to invest 3+ in one commodity and hope that it is worth more than the other three, in which case I should just invest all 5 in it because it is worth more than the other three”.

That is exactly what happened. By putting all eggs in one basket you pretty much have 1 in 4 chances of winning since; at the end of the day, at least one commodity will be worth the most. I only reasoned this out two days after launching Manila so it was too late to change anything. Next time I promise a better luck-based game.

Interestingly each commodity had at least one person who invested all 5 in. Without further ado, let’s take a look at the final net worth after all the spills had been subtracted:

manilares1Ginseng’s the most promising commodity here!
And here are the results:

The 4 people who struck richest are; Zach Polansky, you and I know him as Jack Lance, who run his own puzzle blog with on and off weeks introducing themed gimmicks each time. He was third to reach Manila Bay Pier. Next we have James McGowan, previous winner of Race up the Sky, looking to win his second event. I enjoy his commentary that comes along with all his submissions very much, an SOTR regular. Another past winner is Thomas Powell, joint winner in Anchors Aweigh last year and almost won again in Nikoli Hurdles 2, now another shot at Manila. Notice how regulars seem to have more chances of winning? Enter! Enter!
And rounding up the top investors is Michael Mosshammer, I sat behind him at the 24HPC this year exchanging a few words throughout the day. He and the other 3 now compete for the top 2 prizes.

Tie-break; each competitor is given an extra 3 pesos to invest in the remaining commodities. Everyone was told about the situation: 4 people and looking for 2 winners.

Before we get there, I also promised a third prize. Zbigniew Laskowski was the last submission just before the deadline making the total of entries reach exactly 23. This means that essentially, the last prize will be awarded to the person who came in last place!
We have two competitors tied with this distinction: Nick Brady, a regular at SOTR since Colour Restore and Robert Vollmert, another puzzler I met in Hungary last April. They were also given another 3 pesos but were only told that they were competing for the 23rd-place prize (crucially, were not told to aim for last place).

Let’s announce the 3 winners:
manilares3 Congratulations to Zach Polansky from the United States, Michael Mosshammer from Austria and Nick Brady from the United States! 
Zach will receive Specially Selected Nurikabe, Michael will receive Specially Selected Masyu and Nick gets the Specially Selected Fillomino.

Now we have another event wrapped up!
After a few posts about details of Manila, my next event will be announced.

If you don’t want to miss future events, click the subscribe button on the right hand side of this page and have updates sent to your inbox. A blogger can only stay as long as his readers are still around so thank you all for participating!

Until next time!

3 days left!

9/6/15 – **Submissions to Manila are now closed. Please wait for results to be calculated.

We are anchoring in just under 72 hours.
If you’re still out there, now is the time to hurry!

I always send a confirmation email back to all entrants, so if you have entered and have yet to receive a reply – try resending your entry (after checking your spam inbox).
I’ve taken a peek at the current standings and the possibility of a tie-breaker is likely.
So after the deadline, try check your emails as there might be a tie-breaker to decide the winners.

Next time you’ll hear from me is the announcing of the winner of Manila!
Until then.